When you're shopping for flooring tile stone for a kitchen backsplash, shower wall, or mid-century bathroom refresh, the first decision often seems like color. But between two vintage-looking Daltile ceramic tiles-one glossy electric blue and one matte orange-the practical differences are coverage, finish, and how much wall you actually need to cover. This head-to-head comparison helps you decide which one fits your project.
Quick Verdict
Start with the Matte Orange box if you need to fill a real section of wall, because it costs USD 19.99 per order. Choose the Vintage Blue pack for a glossy electric-blue accent or sample-sized order; it costs USD 41.57.
At a Glance
| Attribute | Vintage Blue Ceramic Tile | Matte Orange Ceramic Tile |
|---|---|---|
| Price | USD 41.57 | USD 19.99 |
| Coverage per order | About 1 ft² | 6 ft² |
| Finish | Glossy | Matte |
| Color | Electric blue | Orange |
| Country of origin | United States | Mexico |
| Slip resistance (DCOF) | 0.42-0.44 | ≥ 0.42 |
Where Each Product Wins
The Vintage Blue tile wins for compact projects: the glossy color pops in a niche, a small backsplash, or as a sample before you order a larger quantity. The Matte Orange tile wins when you need more material per order; its matte finish is less shiny, and the box is sized for a meaningful section of wall.
Product Notes
Vintage Blue Ceramic Tile 4.25 in Subway Square
This glossy electric-blue tile is the better pick when the project is an accent rather than a whole wall. The order is a small pack with 10 pieces, so it works as a realistic sample or a compact feature area. The tile is listed as waterproof and water-resistant, and the DCOF rating of 0.42-0.44 gives you a slip-resistant surface for a shower or backsplash. It has a straight edge and is made in the United States. The limitation is coverage: the pack is tiny in terms of square footage, so a full wall means buying several orders. If you want to test the Daltile Color 1194 blue before committing, this pack is the easiest way to do it.
1 Box -50 Tiles (6 ft²) - Matte Orange 4x4 Ceramic Subway Tile
This matte orange tile is the better pick if you have a larger area to fill. The box holds 50 tiles and covers six times the area of the blue pack, so it moves you from sampling to installing. The matte Tuscany finish cuts glare, and the straight edge with self-spacing lugs support neat spacing. It's a Daltile ceramic tile made in Mexico, with a break strength of over 175 pounds and a slip-resistance rating of at least 0.42. The limitation is color commitment: orange is a strong mid-century statement, so the box only makes sense if that's the palette you want. If you need a lot of tile in one order, this is the practical route.
Final Choice by Use Case
Use the Vintage Blue Ceramic Tile for a glossy blue accent wall, a shower niche, or a sample order that lets you live with the electric-blue color before scaling up. Use the Matte Orange Ceramic Tile for a larger backsplash, a laundry room wall, or any project where you want to cover more area in one order. The orange box is the stronger start when there are cuts to make; the blue pack is the gentler introduction to a bold color.
